Silicone Strips or Creams? Here's What Works

When you're dealing with scars, you have two proven medical-grade options that can reduce their appearance: silicone scar sheets (strips) and silicone gels (creams). Understanding which treatment works best for your specific situation will help you make the right choice for your scar healing journey.

Medical Grade Silicone Scar Sheets

Nuvadermis Silicone Scar Sheets deliver advanced scar treatment technology designed to soften and smooth your scars. Our large scar sheets are ideally sized for hypertrophic scars and keloids, particularly long surgical scars such as C-section scars or larger injuries and burns.

• Medical Grade Silicone Scar Sheet

• Advanced Scar Treatment Technology

• Reduce redness & Discomfort

• Visibly improve the appearance in 4 weeks

General

Both products are very similar in terms of overall effectiveness. In other words, if both products are consistently used as directed, both should perform similarly. [1] However, the key differences lie in application, comfort, and suitability for different scar types and locations.

Our Nuvadermis Silicone Scar Sheets soften your skin to avoid discomfort from everyday movement. They're designed to be flexible and breathable for improved comfort. Silicone gel sheets are reusable and can be washed with soap and water to expand their lifespan for up to two weeks or more. [2]

Silicone Scar Sheets vs Silicone Gels: The Comparison

Silicone Scar Sheets (Strips) Benefits

EFFECTIVENESS – Very effective at improving the size and intensity of scars. [1] For Raised or Keloid Scars: Silicone scar sheets are often recommended due to their ability to apply constant pressure, which is beneficial in flattening the scar. [3]

CUSTOMIZABLE – Sheets are available in different sizes and shapes for all types of scars, but they also can be easily cut to appropriate size for individual needs. [1]

REUSABLE – Can be re-used over time if cared for properly. [1]

CONSISTENT PRESSURE – Ideal for raised scars that need continuous compression to flatten properly.

LIMITATIONS – Difficult to use on certain areas of the body such as joints, skin folds and facial features. [1] Must be cleaned on a regular basis, as sticky surfaces tend to attract debris. [1]

Silicone Gel Benefits

VERSATILITY – Very effective at improving the size and intensity of scars. Can be applied easily and conveniently to just about any area of the body. [1]

DISCRETION – Is clear in appearance so nobody knows you are wearing it. [1] It's virtually invisible once applied, making it an excellent choice for daytime use and on exposed skin areas. [3]

EASE OF USE – Only a small amount is needed … a little goes a long way. [1] Apply 2-3 times daily on clean, dry skin. [3]

LIMITATIONS – Is a bit tacky/ greasy, but if a little time is taken to wipe away the excess after application, this shouldn't prove to be much of an issue. [1] Since it is clear, the scar remains visible whereas the sheeting covers and hides the scar. [1]

Top Rated Silicone Scar Sheets: Customer Reviews & Ratings

Nuvadermis: Leading Alternative to Traditional Brands

When comparing silicone scar sheet options, you'll want to consider customer feedback and ratings. Here's what real users are saying about different brands:

Customer Rating Insights:

• ScarAway Silicone Sheets are another effective choice, boasting a solid 4.1-star rating overall on Amazon, after 4,600-plus reviews, to back them up. [4]

• Amazon rating: 4.3/5 stars An Amazon reviewer says: "Love these silicone scar sheets!" [5]

User Experience Feedback: I truly can't believe how well this works. So amazing. I put it on for a week and it shrinks. [6]

No matter how the scar originated or whether or not it was surgical-based — users mention myriad cases, like ACL knee surgery, a mastectomy, and an oven burn — the consensus is that they work well and they work fast: "I felt my scars flattening after just one day of use." [4]

Common User Concerns with Competitor Products

Adhesion Issues:

• Not even 24 hrs the tape started lifting. I have no clue if it's willing to stay on for 10 days until I change the sheet. [7]

• They are supposedly suppose to last up to 2 weeks for each patch but for me only lasted 2 days. I used on clean dry skin. [8]

Application Difficulties:

• My problem with the Scaraway Silicone Scar Sheets is that the ends will curl under when I try to put one on, and the sheet will stick to itself. [8]

Comparing Nuvadermis to Traditional Alternatives

Why Choose Nuvadermis Over Traditional Brands?

Superior Quality: While traditional scar sheet brands often have adhesion problems, Nuvadermis offers improved durability and comfort.

Better Value: Very expensive if you only get one use out of it. [9] Many users report that traditional brands aren't truly reusable, making Nuvadermis a more cost-effective choice.

Enhanced Comfort: These are the best silicone sheets for surgery scars. These are thicker so they add more protection from your scar rubbing on your clothes or sheets while you're sleeping. They're also a lot more comfortable.

Which Option Works Best for You?

Choose Nuvadermis Silicone Sheets If You Have:

• Large Surgical Scars: Perfect for C-section scars, mastectomy scars, or long incisions

• Raised or Keloid Scars: Silicone scar sheets are often recommended due to their ability to apply constant pressure, which is beneficial in flattening the scar. [3]

• Body Scars: Ideal for areas that can be covered and don't require frequent touching

• Time for Consistent Wear: Best results with 12+ hours daily use

Choose Silicone Gel If You Have:

• Facial Scars: For Smaller, Sensitive Areas: Silicone gel is preferable for its ease of application and suitability for delicate or hard-to-reach areas. [3]

• Joint Areas: More flexible application over areas that move frequently

• Multiple Small Scars: Gel: More suitable due to targeted application on smaller scars. [3]

• Visible Areas: Where discretion is important during daytime

Direction to Use

1. Start using Nuvadermis Silicone Sheets as soon as your wound has closed and the scabs are gone.

2. Wash and dry the scar before applying the silicone sheet.

3. Remove the protective film from the adhesive side of the sheet.

4. Apply the adhesive side to your skin over the scar, ensuring it extends around one inch beyond the edge.

5. If necessary, secure the sheet in place with an adhesive or elastic bandage.

6. For best results, leave the sheet on for at least 12 hours but not more than 23 hours.

7. For the best results on newer scars use the patches consistently for six to eight weeks. For older scars use for four to six months for noticeable results. [5]

Warning

• In rare cases, your skin may have a hypersensitive reaction to silicone sheet. Stop using until the skin is no longer irritated.

• If skin problems persist, consult your healthcare professional.

• For external use only

• For use only on healed, closed skin

• Keep out of reach of children

Customer Feedback: What Real Users Say

Positive Results: I could not believe the change in my scar after just one week. [6]

I have horrid, thick, ridged scarring from chest surgery and skin degradation where a large area of skin died and had to regrow and I've been using this product for 2 weeks now and the hard, thick ridges of scar tissue are noticeably softer and the color of the scars is lightening quite quickly.

Professional Recommendations: My surgeon's PA recommended this product. [7]

An Amazon reviewer says: "I had a double mastectomy, and this product was suggested by my plastic surgeon during recovery. I have been using it for a few months now, and I think it has helped make my scars soft and pliable like the surrounding tissue." [5]

Nuvadermis Products

Nuvadermis Silicone Scar Sheets (Small)

Scar Sheet 1.4×3 inches

Perfect for smaller scars and targeted treatment areas.

Nuvadermis Silicone Scar Sheets (Large)

Scar Sheet 1.4×7 inches

Ideal for C-section scars and larger surgical incisions.

Nuvadermis Advanced Scar Gel

Gel Format - Fast Absorbing

Perfect complement for areas where sheets aren't practical.

Nuvadermis Scar Fading Bundle

Complete Scar Treatment System

Get the complete solution that combines the benefits of both sheets and gel for maximum results.

Your Next Steps to Better Skin

Most people seem to prefer the silicone gel over the sheeting for its overall ease of use. Ease of use typically leads to better results, as patients are more likely to consistently follow the recommended treatment plan when a product is more convenient for them to use. [1]

However, the choice largely depends on the type, size, and location of your scar, as well as personal convenience and lifestyle factors. For dynamic areas or sensitive skin, gels are a go-to, while sheets excel in providing consistent treatment for larger, flatter scars. Understanding your specific needs and scar characteristics will guide you to the most effective silicone-based scar treatment for optimal healing and minimal scarring. [3]

Ready to start your scar treatment journey? Visit Nuvadermis today to explore our complete range of advanced scar treatment solutions. Whether you choose our silicone sheets, advanced gel, or combination bundle, you'll have the tools you need to help reduce the appearance of your scars and feel confident in your skin again.