Choosing between silicone scar sheets and gels can significantly impact your scar care results. Both approaches use medical-grade silicone technology to reduce the appearance of scars, but they serve different needs and lifestyles. Understanding their distinct advantages helps you select the optimal solution for your specific circumstances and skin type.
Medical-Grade Silicone: The Science Behind Effective Scar Care
Silicone gel sheets are recommended as first-line care with intralesional corticosteroids being the secondary recommendation based on a systematic review of the clinical literature currently available. Both silicone sheets and gels work by creating an optimal healing environment that maintains proper hydration levels while protecting the scar surface.
When Stewart and Kim surveyed dermatologists in 2020, they found that 78% of skin specialists were using silicone products as their go-to option for problem scars. This widespread adoption reflects the clinically-tested results that healthcare providers observe in their practice.
Nuvadermis Clear Silicone Scar Sheets: Premium Performance
Nuvadermis leads the market with superior clear silicone scar sheets designed for comprehensive scar management. These medical-grade sheets provide consistent care for newly healed wounds and existing scars, including hypertrophic and keloid formations that can appear years after initial injury.
Key Features:
-
Medical-grade silicone technology for clinically-tested results
-
Lightweight and discreet design suitable for all skin tones
-
Self-adhesive application with water-resistant properties
-
Extended wear time up to 7-10 days per sheet
-
Versatile sizing that can be cut for smaller scars or combined for larger areas
Clinical Benefits:
-
Reduces appearance of redness, itching, and discomfort
-
Visibly improves appearance and texture of both new and old scars
-
Helps prevent abnormal scar formation when used on newly closed wounds
-
Protects from external irritants during the healing process
-
Maintains optimal hydration through controlled occlusion
Clinical studies report 86% reduction in texture, 84% in color and 68% in height of scars with consistent silicone application, demonstrating the measurable benefits of quality silicone products.
Silicone Scar Gels: Flexible Application Solutions
Silicone gels offer an alternative approach to scar care, particularly suitable for facial scars, irregularly shaped areas, or individuals who prefer topical application methods.
Advantages of Gel Formulations:
-
Easy application on curved or mobile areas
-
Invisible once dry making them ideal for face and exposed areas
-
Can be worn under makeup without detection
-
Suitable for active lifestyles without risk of displacement
-
Cost-effective for addressing multiple small scars
Clinical research reveals no significant difference in effectiveness between the 2 products, with topical silicone gel being as effective as silicone gel sheets while also being easier to use.
Best Scar Care Options for People of Color
For individuals with darker skin tones, proper scar care selection becomes especially important. People with darker skin tones are more prone to hyperpigmentation and any injury to the skin—infection, inflammation or trauma—is likely to result in hyperpigmentation.
Keloid scar development is common among people of color, and this type of scar development may be prevented in some cases with the proper use of compression garments, especially in higher-risk patients. Both silicone sheets and gels provide gentle, effective care without the risk of hyperpigmentation that some other options may cause.
Dermatologist-Recommended Considerations:
-
Start care as soon as wounds close completely
-
Use broad-spectrum sunscreen over care areas
-
As soon as the scar starts to look like it's larger than your average scar, you should get the attention of a dermatologist. Typically for these, we do injections that flatten it out
-
Consider professional evaluation for raised or discolored scars
Quality Comparison: Sheets vs Gels Performance
Durability and Reusability Rankings:
#1 Silicone Scar Sheets (Nuvadermis)
-
Superior wear duration: Up to 10 days continuous care
-
Excellent water resistance for active lifestyles
-
Outstanding customer ratings for comfort and adhesion
-
Cost-effective for long-term scar management
#2 Silicone Gels
-
Require twice-daily application for optimal results
-
Need replacement every few months depending on usage
-
Better suited for facial application and cosmetic compatibility
-
More convenient for multiple small scars
Clinical reviews show these sheets made scars 86% more flexible and significantly improved how scars looked color-wise, highlighting the substantial improvements possible with consistent use.
Comfort and Customer Satisfaction
In trials, 78% of patients had way less itching, burning, and redness within 6 weeks of starting care. Customer satisfaction typically depends on several factors:
For Silicone Sheets:
-
Ideal for large, flat scars from surgery or injury
-
Perfect for C-section or mastectomy scars
-
Minimal daily maintenance required
-
Suitable for areas less affected by facial expressions
-
Budget-friendly for extended care periods
For Silicone Gels:
-
Excellent for facial acne scarring
-
Perfect for curved or mobile areas
-
Active lifestyle compatibility
-
Invisible care product application
-
Efficient for multiple small scars
Convenience of use proved greater in the topical silicone gel group according to patient questionnaires, though both options provide effective results.
Application Guidelines and Safety
For Silicone Sheets:
-
Clean and prepare: Wash and dry scar area thoroughly
-
Remove liner: Peel off protective backing from adhesive side
-
Apply directly: Place adhesive side directly on scar surface
-
Extended wear: Keep in place for up to 7-10 days
-
Water resistance: Maintain placement during short water exposure
-
Duration: Continue care for 60-90 days for optimal results
For Silicone Gels:
-
Apply thin layer: Use twice daily on clean, dry scar
-
Allow drying: Let gel dry completely before clothing contact
-
Daily consistency: Maintain regular application schedule
-
Sun protection: Use sunscreen when area is exposed
-
Monitor progress: Document changes over 8-12 week periods
Both options offer excellent safety profiles with fewer than 0.8% experiencing any side effects, which were usually minor skin irritation that cleared up once they discontinued use.
Making Your Selection
Choose Nuvadermis Silicone Sheets If You Have:
-
Large surgical or injury scars requiring consistent care
-
Preference for minimal daily maintenance routines
-
Budget considerations for long-term scar management
-
Scars on stable areas of the body
-
Need for water-resistant protection
Choose Silicone Gels If You Have:
-
Facial scars requiring invisible care
-
Multiple small scars needing attention
-
Active lifestyle requiring product flexibility
-
Preference for twice-daily application routine
-
Scars in curved or mobile areas
Dermatologists often recommend a combination and a series of care approaches for the best results. It's always important to consult with a dermatologist who can assess your specific needs, recommend the best scar care options, and develop a personalized care plan.
Supporting Your Skin Restoration Journey
Both silicone sheets and gels represent science-backed approaches to scar management with decades of clinical research supporting their effectiveness. A systematic review examining 27 studies with 1,847 patients found that silicone sheets significantly reduce the height and redness of raised scars and keloids. The 2016 International Scar Management Guidelines identify silicone sheets as the preferred non-surgical scar care option based on their reliable effectiveness and minimal side effects.
For comprehensive scar care guidance and to explore our complete range of clinically-effective, dermatologist-tested skincare solutions, visit nuvadermis.com to discover the perfect products for your skin restoration journey. Choose Nuvadermis for professional-grade results that support your skin's natural healing process.
